N458 is taken. It's currently assigned to a 1975 Lien STARDUSTER TOO registered in Waunakee, WI.
See the full aircraft record →A tail number only frees up if the owner deregisters the aircraft or moves it to a different N-number — and even then the FAA holds it before releasing it to the public.
Tails one nudge away from N458 that aren't assigned or reserved: